Jeffrey Epstein's brother Mark Epstein argues that new forensic evidence proves Jeffrey was murdered, not a suicide
Tucker Carlson interviews Mark Epstein, brother of Jeffrey Epstein, following the release of a new independent forensic report by Dr. Michael Baden concluding that Jeffrey Epstein could not have died by suicide.
Summary
Tucker Carlson interviews Mark Epstein, Jeffrey Epstein's brother, in the wake of a new independent forensic investigation by Dr. Michael Freeman — a pathologist who created a 3D digital model of Jeffrey Epstein's body using autopsy photographs and records — concluding that the injuries were inconsistent with suicide by hanging and consistent with homicide. Mark Epstein describes how the two pathologists present at the original autopsy, Dr. Kristin Roman and Dr. Michael Baden, both said they could not rule it a suicide because it looked too much like a homicide — yet the chief medical examiner, Barbara Samson, who was not present at the autopsy and never viewed the body, ruled it a suicide just four days later. Mark Epstein identifies a number of specific anomalies: the destruction of the crime scene, the disappearance of the noose, an unidentified name on the prison tier roster that cannot be traced in court records, a discrepancy in the inmate count the night Epstein died, and the fact that the guard who allegedly found Epstein hanging (Michael Thomas) did not speak to investigators for two years while under indictment for falsifying prison records — along with his fellow guard Tova Noel. Mark Epstein states that Jeffrey told him in 2016 that if he revealed what he knew about the presidential candidates, "they'd have to cancel the election," and argues that whoever orchestrated the murder must have had the authority to direct the DOJ to cover it up — pointing to the president of the United States as the logical person of interest in any serious investigation. He calls for an independent congressional investigation rather than a DOJ inquiry, which he regards as compromised. To illustrate the anomaly of the non-investigation, Mark Epstein contrasts the Epstein case with the murder of Whitey Bulger in federal prison, where the DOJ did pursue and charge the perpetrators without any cover-up.
Key Takeaways
- The two pathologists who performed the autopsy refused to call it a suicide, saying it looked more like a homicide. Chief Medical Examiner Barbara Samson, who was not present at the autopsy and never viewed the body, overruled them and declared suicide within four days — with no documented basis for that conclusion, in contrast to Dr. Freeman's extensively evidenced report.
- Dr. Michael Freeman's independent forensic report, built on a 3D digital model of Epstein's body mapped with all documented injuries, concludes the injuries — including blunt force trauma to the back of the neck and bruising inconsistent with a suicidal hanging — could not have resulted from suicide. The report is publicly available and Freeman has invited peer scrutiny.
- Epstein's body was not "pristine" as the government claimed. The autopsy photographs show bruising on his neck, back, face, and mouth. The mouth bruising is particularly significant: bruising requires blood pressure, meaning those injuries were inflicted while Epstein was still alive — yet he had been dead for hours before being found.
- The crime scene was destroyed and key evidence has disappeared, including the noose. No photographs were taken of Epstein in the cell. The medical examiner was prevented from visiting the crime scene, which Mark Epstein describes as highly unusual. The guard who allegedly found Epstein hanging, Michael Thomas, did not speak to investigators for two years while under indictment for falsifying prison records.
- An unidentified name appeared in Bureau of Prisons computer records that did not appear on the official tier roster and could not be traced in any court records — coinciding with a discrepancy in the inmate count the night Epstein died, where the count dropped by one person who was not Epstein.
- Bill Barr's public claim that he personally reviewed surveillance footage and saw that nobody entered or exited the tier has since been shown to be false: the footage does not show the door to the tier, and the staircase leading to it has a blind side that would not be captured on camera. An orange-clad figure was subsequently identified ascending that staircase in the middle of the night.
- Jeffrey Epstein told his brother in 2016 that if he revealed what he knew about the presidential candidates, "they'd have to cancel the election." He did not specify which candidate or what the information was, but referred to both candidates.
- Mark Epstein argues the perpetrator must be someone with authority over the DOJ, since the cover-up involves the FBI, DOJ, and OIG all deferring to Samson's unsupported ruling. He identifies the president of the United States as the logical person of interest in any serious investigation, noting that Kash Patel's dismissal of the case — "you know a suicide when you see one" — was made without Patel having been present or having any forensic basis for the claim.
- Mark Epstein is calling for an independent congressional investigation, not a DOJ inquiry, which he regards as irreparably compromised. He wants the medical examiner to be required to publicly defend her suicide ruling against Dr. Freeman's documented findings.
FULL TRANSCRIPT
Opening: The forensic basis for concluding Epstein was murdered
Tucker Carlson: Mark Epstein, thank you very much for doing this. People often say Jeffrey Epstein didn't kill himself, and it's kind of an internet meme — it's a joke. But based on two separate studies of the autopsy results, I think we can say conclusively Jeffrey Epstein really didn't kill himself. Is that your conclusion?
Mark Epstein: Yeah, that's been my thinking all along. But now we have proof. Up until this point, there was always a he said, she said kind of thing. Some people said the government's trying to say he committed suicide, and right-thinking people said no, he didn't kill himself. And now we have proof, basically, that he didn't kill himself. So that only leaves homicide.
Tucker Carlson: Can we start at the beginning? How exactly did the government decide that your brother killed himself in the first place? Where did the ruling of suicide come from?
Mark Epstein: Well, it's an interesting question, because when they first did the autopsy — the day after he died — I fully expected the two doctors that were there, Dr. Roman, who was a city pathologist and whose autopsy it was to conduct, and Dr. Michael Baden, who was there on my behalf because I had the right to have my own pathologist witness the autopsy — I thought they would come out of the autopsy room saying, "I'm sorry, but your brother killed himself." But that's not what happened. They came out of the autopsy saying that they couldn't call it a suicide because it looked too much like a homicide.
Until that moment, I fully believed Jeff killed himself. I had no reason to doubt it up to that point, because I heard on the news he was found dead from an apparent suicide. Why question it? But when two very highly qualified pathologists said, "It looks more like a homicide than a suicide," I started saying, "Well, what's going on here?"
And then, in a matter of days — four or five days later — Barbara Samson, who was the chief medical examiner, determined it was a suicide. My question is: how did she come up with that determination? Because on the initial death certificate, the cause of death said "pending further study." The pathologists I've spoken to have said that when an initial death certificate says "pending further study," you usually don't get a determination for weeks or months because something's being studied. But it seems like nothing was studied here.
Dr. Freeman — I gave him all of the information: the autopsy reports, the photographs, medical records, whatever I had. He worked on this for months and months to come up with the determination that this could not have been a suicide. So how did the medical examiner's office determine it was a suicide in four days? It boggles the imagination.
Tucker Carlson: And to be clear, Barbara Samson, the medical examiner who ultimately ruled this a suicide, was not present at the autopsy, and the two physicians — the two pathologists who were at the autopsy — said they could not declare it a suicide. So the people with actual firsthand experience of the autopsy reached a different conclusion. What do we know about why she changed their conclusion and ruled it a suicide?
Mark Epstein: No, we don't. Michael Freeman's report is backed up by lots of exhibits and evidence showing how he came to his conclusions. We have nothing like that from Barbara Samson. As a matter of fact, on the government side, they were saying — and it's pointed out in Dr. Freeman's report — that other than the marks on Jeffrey's neck, Jeffrey's body was pristine. That's the word they use, meaning there were no other marks, no other bruises. But we know from the photographs and the actual written autopsy report that there were other bruises on his body that could not have been caused by a suicidal hanging.
And Barbara Samson — not only was she not at the autopsy, she never saw Jeffrey's body anywhere. It's not like she had an independent viewing of the body, because after the autopsy the body was taken away. And she wasn't even in the office that day. It was a Sunday.
And then Bill Barr, the attorney general, came out and said that he personally saw the videotape from outside the tier where Jeff was held, and he saw that nobody went in or out of the tier, and that convinced him it was a suicide. When I heard that, I said, "This is bullshit" — if I can say that on your show.
Tucker Carlson: Yeah.
Mark Epstein: Because number one, he completely ignored the possibility that somebody already on the tier — like another inmate or a prison official — could have done something. And then when the videotape he was referring to was finally released a couple of years ago, you could see that you cannot see the door to the tier in that footage. And it's been shown that if you stayed to the right-hand side of the staircase leading to that door, you wouldn't be caught on camera. So theoretically, a dozen people could have walked up the right-hand side of that staircase, gone into the tier, sat down and had a tea party, and left going down the right-hand side of the staircase, and they wouldn't be caught on camera. So just what the hell was Bill Barr referring to?
Tucker Carlson: I don't really think he's that stupid.
Mark Epstein: No, I hope he's not stupid. But to come up with that statement saying he saw that nobody went in or out of the tier — that videotape does not show that at all. And then we know now there's that orange figure going up the staircase in the middle of the night. They don't know if it's a prisoner in orange prison garb or somebody carrying sheets, but somebody went up that staircase and could have gone into the tier. So he said nobody went in or out. It's a completely fictitious statement. I would like to be able to question him in a room.
And then also, Bill Barr, under oath in a congressional testimony last year, when he was asked about Dr. Baden's comment about it looking more like a homicide — Dr. Baden's opinion that this was a homicide — he said, "Baden came after the fact." That was his quote under oath. "Baden came after the fact." No — the fact is, Baden was there for the entire autopsy. Barbara Samson came after the fact.
And then they say there were investigations by the FBI, the DOJ, and the OIG. All of these investigations relied on Barbara Samson's determination of suicide. So when the New York Times wrote about it, and various other investigations said suicide, they were all based on her statement, and there's no backup. These other supposed investigations by these other organizations — you can't see a record of anything. You can't see what they studied. They just determined it, and all those organizations are part of the DOJ. So you can't believe that. There's no backup. With Dr. Freeman's report, it was done scientifically.
Tucker Carlson: Did you see his presentation?
Mark Epstein: Yes. He did it scientifically. They went through the whole process. For your listeners who didn't see it: they created a 3D digital model of Jeffrey's body, and on it, from the photographs and the autopsy results, they placed all of the injuries — on his not-pristine body. And they show that these could not have come from a suicide. Especially the one on the back of his neck — it wouldn't happen that way. It's blunt force trauma. There's damage to the muscles under the skin. It's a very thorough report. I'm not a pathologist, but it's very convincing. Everyone who sees it says it's completely convincing.
Bill Barr, Barbara Samson, and the cover-up
Tucker Carlson: Just to pause for a second on the initial statement of suicide made by Barbara Samson and then backed up by the then-attorney general Bill Barr — who, and I've said this publicly and I'll say it again, clearly covered up the murder of your brother. He threatened to sue me. He hasn't. I would welcome that lawsuit. Barbara Samson — who is she? Has she ever spoken to this? Has she ever explained in public why she called what was clearly a murder a suicide? Has anyone asked her?
Mark Epstein: Not to my knowledge. I've tried to speak to her, but I can't get to her. She won't respond to me. I've tried to email her, tried to call. I can't get to her.
Tucker Carlson: Has anyone in the media staked out her office? Has anyone pushed on this?
Mark Epstein: She's no longer with the medical examiner's office. I think she's working in a private hospital somewhere.
Tucker Carlson: I'm not alleging anything at all, but I keep sticking on the fact that Bill Barr's father was the headmaster of Dalton School and hired your brother. It seems like the odds of that, in a country of hundreds of millions of people, are very, very small.
Mark Epstein: Yeah. I understand that's the case, but I'd be really surprised if Jeffrey was getting involved with anything — with espionage or anything like that — back when he first started teaching at Dalton. I mean, he was just done with college. I'd be really surprised. He didn't mention anything to me about that back then. And again, it becomes a he said, she said. There's no proof of anything.
Tucker Carlson: I'm speaking more of Bill Barr. I just think the odds that the attorney general who covers up the murder of Jeffrey Epstein is the son of the guy who first hired Jeffrey Epstein — I'm not alleging anything, I have no knowledge at all, but I just think the odds of that have got to be infinitesimally small.
Mark Epstein: Yeah, but coincidences happen. It's Bill Barr, not his father. And I don't know if it was Mr. Barr, the father, who actually hired Jeffrey, or if it was somebody from the math department who hired Jeffrey. I have no idea what the process was there. So I really can't comment on that.
Dr. Michael Freeman's independent investigation
Tucker Carlson: So this new investigation led by Dr. Michael Freeman, a pathologist — how did this come about?
Mark Epstein: He contacted me about a year ago. Up until that point I had never heard of him. I didn't know about his work or anything, but he had seen what was out there — the pictures of Jeffrey's neck. And when I first saw Jeffrey's body and I saw the marks on his neck, I thought, "This is not a hanging." It's too low on his neck for it to be a hanging. I'm not a forensic pathologist, but it was one of those obvious things — if you know about bodies and how things go, it just became obvious. It doesn't look like a hanging mark. It looks more like strangulation. But I can't make that call.
I give the example: when you walk out of your house in the morning and the ground is wet and there are puddles and the cars are all wet and water's dripping from the leaves — you might not have seen it rain, but you know it rained. You don't need a meteorologist to tell you it rained. That's how I felt about Jeffrey's body, about the marks on his body.
So Dr. Freeman contacted me. He wanted to look into this because this is his life's work — he goes through cases where there have been bad determinations on cause of death. I realized he was a serious person and I gave him all the information I had. We didn't have much contact between then and now. I would text or email him once in a while to find out if anything new was coming up. The first time I saw the full report was Monday night when he gave his presentation. I didn't see the whole report prior to that.
And it's independent. People think I paid him for this — I didn't. This was not done on my behalf. He did this for the science of it, to keep the field pure.
Tucker Carlson: Well, it's clearly not pure. And if the medical examiner who ruled against the judgment of the attending pathologists won't even answer questions about why she did, then I think we're looking at pretty obvious corruption. I can't think of another explanation for it.
Mark Epstein: And even more — what I find almost comical — is that more recently, Kash Patel, the head of the FBI, also under congressional testimony under oath, when he was asked about this, he said, "You know a suicide when you see one." He has said that in other venues as well. And I thought: just how stupid is this? How many suicides has he actually seen, that he can compare this to? And he was not there when Jeffrey was killed. He didn't see Jeffrey's body. So "you know a suicide when you see one" — just how ludicrous is it for him to make a statement like that?
The noose, the note, and the crime scene
Tucker Carlson: Let me ask about a couple of details. If you're investigating a suicide, one of the key pieces of evidence is the noose the deceased used to kill himself. What happened to the noose in your brother's case?
Mark Epstein: Your guess is as good as mine. It's gone. We don't know. The whole crime scene was destroyed. No pictures were taken of Jeffrey at any time that we know of. They should have been. When he was found, he was clearly dead — he had been dead for quite a while. If you saw the picture of the groove in his neck, that alone is an indication he'd been dead for a while, because in order for that groove to stay in his neck like that, rigor mortis has set in and the skin is drying out. He was cold when they found him. So why this charade to make it look like he was survivable? They intubated him, they were blowing air into him with a balloon. It's a charade, as far as I'm concerned. He was dead.
So the noose is gone. We're not sure of anything about it. Although in the room on the side there was a knotted loop, which Dr. Freeman thinks might have been what was used to strangle him. He shows it in his presentation.
Tucker Carlson: There was a note found in your brother's cell, and I think a lot of people assumed it was a suicide note. Now we know roughly what was in it. What was in that note?
Mark Epstein: Well, it appeared to be a suicide-type note. But even so — that note was supposedly written when he was in the cell with Tartaglione, which was weeks prior to the August event when they said he tried to kill himself. Jeffrey told his attorneys and other people that his cellmate attacked him. It wasn't a suicide attempt. He was initially put on suicide watch because they thought it might be a suicide, but he was quickly taken off of suicide watch, which means they felt he wasn't suicidal. If he was truly suicidal, they would have kept him on suicide watch for quite some time. It would have been irresponsible to remove him from suicide watch if they truly thought he was suicidal.
So the note — Dr. Baden told me that sometimes when they find a true suicide, they'll find a suicide note in the person's wallet that was written quite some time ago. So the note, even if Jeffrey wrote it, doesn't mean he killed himself. Maybe he thought about killing himself at some point, but the autopsy shows he did not kill himself. Simple as that.
Up until this point, it's always been the debate: did he kill himself or not? Well, we now know the answer to that. He didn't kill himself. So now the thing to focus on is: who killed him, or who had him killed? That's the new question.
How Epstein may have died — and who may have been responsible
Tucker Carlson: How do you imagine his final moments went? I know you've reconstructed it in your mind.
Mark Epstein: I believe there was somebody already on the tier who killed him. Because on the other hand, if somebody could get to that tier, go inside, kill somebody, and then leave completely undetected — other than if the cameras are working — that would be foolish. To get to that tier, I think there are six levels of security, because that's the maximum security tier. Each level has its own guards, cameras, and gates. So I think somebody might have been planted there as an inmate to do this.
Also, in the prison, there was a miscount around the night before Jeffrey was found dead. I think there were like 73 people in that ward — not just the tier, the whole ward. And the night after he was found dead, there were like 72 people. There was a missing person, and it's not Jeffrey. Why did the counts get mixed up that particular night? That's a more interesting coincidence than Jeffrey dealing with Barr's father forty or fifty years ago.
Tucker Carlson: Though I remain fascinated by the obvious fact that the attorney general of the United States helped cover up the murder. That seems like something we should care a lot about. You can't have an attorney general covering up the murder of an American citizen. Even a convicted felon — it doesn't matter. You can't murder people.
Mark Epstein: That's why — a lot of people think there were a lot of people that wanted to see Jeffrey dead. I don't necessarily believe that, because I know he was well-liked. Everyone I met that knew Jeffrey seemed to like him and got along well with him. But even if there was a number of people that wanted to see Jeffrey dead, you have to winnow that out. Any investigator would winnow that out to: who can orchestrate this? Who amongst that list could orchestrate having somebody killed in a federal prison and having the DOJ cover it up? Because it's clearly a cover-up.
Tucker Carlson: Clearly. Who would be on that list?
Mark Epstein: Well, if I was an investigator, I would say the president of the United States would be a person of interest. I'm not accusing anybody, but he would have that kind of authority — to sign off on some order to have somebody killed with black ops people and have the DOJ cover it up. Bill Barr, Kash Patel — they all work for the president of the United States. So he should be asked. He should be questioned about this. Any good investigation would point towards him. And maybe — but that's the only one I could think of.
Epstein's 2016 claim about the presidential candidates
Tucker Carlson: What do you think the motive would be?
Mark Epstein: Well, Jeffrey obviously had dirt on him. That's what he said in 2006. And also, I wouldn't put it past him to do something like this. We see what he does.
Tucker Carlson: He said that he had dirt on the president in 2006?
Mark Epstein: He said — if he said what he knew, they'd have to cancel the election. We were talking about the elections. I asked him what he thought was going to happen. He said he didn't know, but he said if he said what he knew, they'd have to cancel the elections. He didn't tell me what he knew, but that's a statement he made. And he wouldn't just say that to me if he didn't know something.
Tucker Carlson: This was the 2016 Hillary versus Trump election you're talking about?
Mark Epstein: Correct. Yeah.
Tucker Carlson: And he just said that to you — "they'd have to cancel the election." Do you know that he was speaking about Trump? Because of course he also knew Hillary.
Mark Epstein: He said if he said what he knew about the candidates — he didn't weigh it to one or the other, but he meant both. If he said what he knew about the candidates, they'd have to cancel the election. That's what he said. That's a quote. He didn't tell me any details about either one, but that was his line: if he said what he knew about the candidates, they'd have to cancel the election.
Tucker Carlson: Could you tell from the context what kind of things he might be talking about?
Mark Epstein: Absolutely not. No. You now know as much about that conversation as I do, because that's all there was. I asked him what he thought was going to happen. He said he didn't know, but if he said what he knew, they'd have to cancel the election. We chuckled and then went on with the rest of our conversation. That's all I know.
Tucker Carlson: It is interesting that he knew them both as well as he did.
Mark Epstein: He knew a lot of people. I'm actually surprised at the vast network he had. I knew he knew a lot of people, but all the stuff that's been coming out has been surprising to me. I didn't see Jeffrey for seven years before he died. We were always in communication — always emailing, phone calls — but we didn't get together. We both had different homes in different cities, so we weren't in the same place frequently. We communicated and that was enough for us.
The night before he flew home and got arrested, he called me. He was in Paris. It was just a normal, brother-to-brother, what's-new kind of phone call. And then he flew home and got arrested. That phone call that night was the last communication I had with him. He was dead within a month — a little just over. I think he was arrested on July 7th or something.
Tucker Carlson: And he died — well, he was declared dead August 10th, I think it was.
Mark Epstein: Yeah. Just a little over a month.
Tucker Carlson: Did he mention in that last conversation — so you talked to him the last day he was free as a man — did he mention being worried about being arrested when he got back to Teterboro Airport?
Mark Epstein: No, not at all. After he was arrested, his attorneys called me to tell me, and they were surprised. They didn't know this was going to happen.
Tucker Carlson: In retrospect, it's a little strange the way that unfolded, because he was basically indicted on the federal version of the same charges he'd been convicted on in Florida thirteen years before — which technically is not double jeopardy, I guess, but it is still sort of double jeopardy. He'd already been convicted on essentially the same charges. There's nothing new that I know of. And then a month and a couple of days later, he's murdered.
Mark Epstein: Right. And he had a non-prosecution agreement from the 2006–2008 period of time. That was going to be a big part of his defense because they were looking to defend Jeffrey — he was in jail. They didn't know why he was arrested. But maybe if you look at this holistically: he comes back from France, he's arrested, and then killed. Maybe the whole point of re-indicting him was to get him into a federal holding facility where he could be murdered.
Tucker Carlson: Knowing the way things happen, that's a logical theory.
Mark Epstein: But it's just a theory. No other information. I don't like speculating. I like to stick with facts. If you're going to speculate, that could be a possible scenario, but that's only an opinion.
The prison tier, the missing inmate, and the guards
Tucker Carlson: Here's a fact that would be interesting to know. If he was murdered — and now we know he likely was — and was likely murdered by someone already on the tier, locked up with him in this most secure portion of the federal prison, then the first question you would ask is: who was there that night? What were the names of the inmates? Where are they now? Who were all the staff? I called the Department of Justice back then, when Bill Barr was attorney general, and they refused to release the names of any of the inmates who were on the tier with your brother when he was murdered. Have you ever received that information?
Mark Epstein: We were able to find some list. I had some people who were interested in this, and they were looking into it and going through computer records. They were able to get into some of the computer records from the Bureau of Prisons, and there was a name that came up that didn't appear on the official list. Maybe that was the missing person. We don't know, because most of the people on the list are prisoners with numbers — you can track where they are. But there was one name that didn't show up, and it didn't show up in court records. If you find out who was on the tier and you search them in the court system, you can see what they were charged with, what court they were in — that's all public. But this one name that came up, there didn't seem to be a trace of it. It was not easily found anywhere they looked.
Tucker Carlson: Did you find out who it is?
Mark Epstein: No. Because when I try to get information from the government, I mostly get stonewalled. Months after the death, I had a meeting with some people from the Justice Department. I was there, Dr. Baden was there, an attorney was with me. And every time I asked them a question about this, all I got was, "After a thorough investigation, we've determined it was a suicide." I would say, "But what about this?" "After a thorough investigation, we determined it was a suicide." It's like when somebody pleads the Fifth Amendment time and time again when they're being interrogated — no matter what the question, they plead the Fifth. It was like they were pleading the Fifth with "after a thorough investigation." And there's been no description of what their thorough investigation actually is.
Dr. Freeman's investigation is documented — the photos, everything's online now. If anyone questions his thinking, he welcomes it. He's an academician. He has an open mind. If somebody can show where he might have made an error, he's open to that. He's not going to stick behind an opinion that might be wrong, because that damages his credibility. And as far as I know, he has impeccable credentials.
The DOJ's posture under Biden and Trump
Tucker Carlson: Did this change under Biden? He died under Trump, then we had Biden, now we've got Trump again. Did the DOJ's posture change under Biden?
Mark Epstein: No. I don't think anyone in the government was pushing for this. I think if I wasn't pushing for this, I don't know how much of these studies would have been done, or if Dr. Freeman would have come across the material to question it. I don't know where or when he initially decided to do this. I only met him for the first time Sunday night, the night before the presentation in London.
Tucker Carlson: How much media attention did this get?
Mark Epstein: A lot. The batteries on my phones have been dying quite a lot from all the calls and interviews people want to do. It's getting a lot of attention.
Tucker Carlson: Why are you doing this?
Mark Epstein: Because I know my brother was killed. Look, my life would have been a lot easier if in fact he committed suicide. When I first heard he was dead from an apparent suicide, I fully believed it. I had no reason to question it. I know he was in jail facing a potentially long time — probably the rest of his life. He was 66 at the time, and in my family the males don't usually last to 100, so he'd probably die in prison if found guilty of everything. He didn't have any children to worry about. Our parents were already gone. I knew he knew he didn't have to worry about me. So if he decided to take himself, I basically respected that decision, because if I was in that kind of position — facing the rest of my life in jail, having had a nice life, no children, parents gone — chances are I might want to do the same. I wouldn't want to spend the rest of my life in jail just merely to stay alive.
But then after the autopsy, when they came out and said they couldn't call it a suicide, things got flipped over. And why I push this — because somebody killed my brother, and I don't just want to walk away from that.
Tucker Carlson: And I'm sure you've thought about this: anyone who can have someone murdered in the most secure tier in federal detention in Manhattan is by definition a powerful, capable force. So it would probably be better for you if you just kind of let it pass.
Mark Epstein: Yeah, you might say that. But that's one of the reasons I don't appear on camera anywhere. I don't need to be recognized. I don't want to be seen. And this is not about me. I don't want the story to be about me. It's just that somebody — who happened to be my brother — was killed in a federal prison, likely by the government, and the government's covering it up. I think people should be aware of that. Because if he could be killed in prison before he was even convicted of anything — he was charged, whatever his crimes were — then it could happen to anybody. This should not be allowed to happen.
Tucker Carlson: I agree with that completely.
What people who knew Epstein believe
Tucker Carlson: You said you hadn't seen your brother in a while, but you spoke regularly. In the last seven years, you've talked to his attorneys and presumably people he knew. Do people who were in touch with your brother before he died think he killed himself?
Mark Epstein: No.
Tucker Carlson: No?
Mark Epstein: No. People that knew Jeff don't think he killed himself.
Tucker Carlson: And I spoke to at least one of his lawyers when you and I first talked some years ago, and that lawyer was convinced he was murdered. Do you think all his attorneys feel that way?
Mark Epstein: Likely. I didn't speak to all of his attorneys, so I can't verify that, but likely. I think any thinking person — put it this way: if you take the predetermination of suicide off the table, take Barbara Samson's initial claim of suicide off the table, and you look at the autopsy the way Dr. Freeman did, there's no way you'd come up with the conclusion that he committed suicide. No way.
Everyone has this thing in their mind that he committed suicide because of what she said, and what Bill Barr and Kash Patel said with those idiotic comments. So people think it was a suicide. But if you look at it objectively from square one, the Freeman report shows it could not have been a suicide.
The physical evidence: injuries, bruising, and the mouth
Tucker Carlson: You cannot attribute those other injuries to his body to a suicide.
Mark Epstein: Right. And again, in the DOJ or the medical examiner's report, they said his body was pristine — other than the ligature marks on his neck, his body was pristine. It was far from pristine. He's got other marks around his neck, his back, his face, his mouth. And one of the pieces of information is that Jeffrey's mouth was bruised up. There are photographs of it. This is not opinion — this is fact. And they showed signs of bleeding.
The government's story is that his mouth got damaged when they were intubating him and they had a mask on him, although I don't know how you damage somebody's mouth by putting an oxygen mask on somebody. That's their excuse. But we know he was dead for quite a while when they found him. Even if they roughed up his mouth when they were intubating him, it wouldn't bleed, because you have no blood pressure anymore.
Tucker Carlson: You won't bleed.
Mark Epstein: So the fact that there were signs of blood — if someone punches you in the lip and your lip hits against your tooth, the tissue inside your lip, the capillaries break, and you get bruising, a discoloration from the blood leaking inside your lip. Well, when you're dead and someone punches you in the mouth, you don't bruise, because there's no more blood pressure. There's no blood getting through. For Jeffrey's mouth bruises to show, he got those bruises while he was still alive. And we know he was dead for hours before he was found.
So if he was dead for hours — if he was cold and going into rigor mortis, which I think the evidence proves he was — why would he be taken to the prison infirmary and intubated?
Tucker Carlson: That's one of the excellent questions out there. Well, if they want to make it look like a suicide, right? You have to understand: he was killed with the assumption that they could make it look like a suicide. They didn't kill him to leave him there as a murder victim, because lots of questions come up. So they kill him and try to make it look like a suicide. They follow the procedure of what you might do with somebody who tried to commit suicide and could still be revived. They thought, as if he was revivable in the cell. They tried to use a defibrillator on him to start his heart again, and the machine said, essentially, don't bother — when they put the paddles on somebody, you can tell that nothing's going to happen. There's no activity at all.
Mark Epstein: So he was dead. They should not have moved the body. They should have taken pictures. They should have called the medical examiner's office. Kristin Roman — one of the reasons she was holding off on making a determination early on was that she said she wanted to go see the crime scene to determine if it was a suicide. She was prevented from going to see the crime scene. That's highly unusual — that the medical examiner's office can't go to the crime scene. Now add that to the list of things that just aren't right.
The guards, the cellmate, and unanswered questions
Tucker Carlson: So the cop killer — the former cop from New York who had multiple murder convictions, who was in the cell with your brother, who your brother said assaulted him — has he ever answered questions about this?
Mark Epstein: Not as far as I know. But to be clear, he wasn't in the cell when Jeffrey was found dead. This was back in July — they were cellmates weeks prior. Was he questioned? I don't know. In most cases, if there's a crime like this, all of the other prisoners on that tier would have been questioned. All of them. There are only like twelve or so. It's not like thousands of potential people. If Jeffrey was killed, it's either by another inmate on the tier, somebody planted there to be an inmate, or some prison official — some guard or correction officer. It's a list of maybe a couple of dozen people who would be on the suspect list of who actually committed the murder. Who ordered it, who orchestrated it — that's a different list. But who was actually able to be there to kill somebody, that's a relatively small list. And it doesn't seem like they really looked at it much.
Also, the guard who supposedly found Jeffrey — Michael Thomas — he's the only person who supposedly saw him hanging when he called for help. Supposedly the other guard who was there, Tova Noel, didn't go into the cell. How odd is that? He finds a dead prisoner and calls for emergency help, says he was hanging, and nobody else went into the cell? That doesn't make sense.
Tucker Carlson: Has Michael Thomas, the guard who says he found your brother hanging, answered questions from anybody?
Mark Epstein: No. That's another thing. Dr. Roman — not only did she want to go to the cell to see the crime scene, she wanted to talk to the guard who supposedly found him hanging. He didn't talk to anybody for two years, because the guards were under investigation, under indictment, because they forged their prison records. They said they made the rounds to check on prisoners when it was shown that they didn't — they were sitting at their computers, surfing the web and napping. So they were being charged with that, because that's a crime.
So that guard, Michael Thomas, didn't speak to anybody for two years. Yet they made a determination of suicide in four days.
Tucker Carlson: Do you know where Michael Thomas is now?
Mark Epstein: No. I've tried to talk to him. He won't talk to me. I've spoken to his attorney. I tried to get to him through his attorney. He and Tova Noel will not speak to me.
Tucker Carlson: Do you think they're afraid?
Mark Epstein: You'd have to ask them that.
Motive, the Whitey Bulger comparison, and the call for an independent investigation
Tucker Carlson: Let me just ask you one final question. Do you have any sense of why someone would go to the effort of killing your brother?
Mark Epstein: Well, I think it would be to shut him up, so he couldn't tell what he knew. I don't see any other reason. I don't see anybody hating Jeffrey enough to kill him just because of who he is. And again, whatever list there might be of people who might have wanted to see Jeffrey harmed — who would have the ability to do something like this and have the DOJ cover it up? Because it's clearly a cover-up.
Contrast this to the case of Whitey Bulger. You know, the criminal who was on the run for twenty years — they found him, put him in jail, and he was supposedly brutally murdered by three other inmates. It turns out he was like a rat for the FBI or something. They brutally murdered him. Well, the DOJ is not covering that up. They found the three guys that beat him up and killed him. They charged them appropriately. There's no sense of a cover-up there. No mystery.
But with Jeffrey, nothing's being answered. They're not doing anything. And they're obviously lying. I actually laughed out loud when Kash Patel said, "You know a suicide when you see one." I actually chuckled out loud. I said, "This idiot — how many suicides has he seen?" And he wasn't there. So when people say, "Well, Kash Patel says it's a suicide" — you can't put any weight on that opinion. He has no knowledge. He has no experience.
I said Jeffrey was killed. I'm not a forensic pathologist, so no one's going to believe me because I don't have the credentials. You know, I could say it rained when I go outside and everything's wet — I'm not a meteorologist, but people will take my word for it. But in this particular case with pathology, no. It's just my opinion. But you get professionals, and other pathologists also believe that Jeffrey was killed.
Tucker Carlson: Mark Epstein, I appreciate you taking the time to have this conversation. I think it's important, and at some point I hope we will have a DOJ that is willing to tell the truth about this. I hope we live to see that. So thank you.
Mark Epstein: Well, I'd like it to be not the DOJ. Some members of Congress now — and more are getting on board — want an independent investigation of Jeffrey's death and autopsy. I don't trust the DOJ to do it because they've been covering everything up. I believe Congress should put an independent investigative body together to investigate the circumstances of Jeffrey's death, reviewing Michael Freeman's work and letting the medical examiner make her argument for why she thinks it was a suicide. That would be a very interesting show.
Tucker Carlson: Yes, it would be. I'm not holding my breath, but —
Mark Epstein: Well, thank you very much. Good to talk to you.
Tucker Carlson: You're welcome. Thank you for the time.