Sermon on Galatians 5:16–25: The Fruit of the Spirit explained through three relational triads
Rev Harry Newton of Sumner Redcliffs Anglican Church delivers a sermon on Galatians 5:16–25, concluding a short series on the Fruit of the Spirit.
Summary
Rev Harry Newton wraps up a multi-week series on the Fruit of the Spirit drawn from Galatians 5:16–25. He provides a brief recap of the series — introducing the apostle Paul, the meaning of "the flesh" (sarx) and the Holy Spirit — before moving into the main body of the sermon, which explores what the nine fruits of the Spirit actually look like in daily life. Drawing on the framework of theologian John Stott, Newton organises the nine fruits into three triads: love, joy, and peace as they relate to God; patience, kindness, and goodness as they relate to others; and faithfulness, gentleness, and self-control as they relate to the self. He works through these triads in reverse order, beginning with the self, then others, then God. He argues that each fruit is the direct opposite of what the sarx produces, and that these qualities are not self-generated character traits but the natural result of the Holy Spirit at work within a person.
Key Takeaways
- The fruit of the Spirit are not a moral checklist. Newton is clear that Paul is not presenting a list of requirements for acceptance by God. Rather, the fruit a person produces reflects who or what they are following — the sarx or the Holy Spirit — and is a window into the orientation of their life.
- The sarx (flesh) produces recognisable modern dysfunction. Using Eugene Peterson's paraphrase, Newton describes the fruit of the sarx as "the accumulation of mental and emotional garbage, frenzied and joyless grabs for happiness, paranoid loneliness, cutthroat competition" — framing it as a pointed description of contemporary culture.
- John Stott's three triads provide a practical framework. Newton uses Stott's structure to show that the nine fruits are not random virtues but map onto three key relationships: with God (love, joy, peace), with others (patience, kindness, goodness), and with oneself (faithfulness, gentleness, self-control).
- Self-control is not willpower. Newton argues that true self-control (Greek: enkrateia) is not about grit or resolution but is the result of the Holy Spirit's presence within a person — a reframing that shifts the source of moral formation from personal effort to spiritual relationship.
- Gentleness is the opposite of self-absorption. Newton connects the Greek word praotēs to a surrender of self-will, arguing that in a society he describes as "ragingly neoliberal" and built around the fulfilment of personal desire, this fruit is profoundly counter-cultural.
- Faithfulness produces an undivided self. Drawing on Tim Keller, Newton argues that pistis (faithfulness) is the opposite of fickleness, and that the Holy Spirit forming faithfulness in a person means their private self and public self genuinely align — a wholeness that mirrors God's own unchanging faithfulness to Israel despite their repeated failures.
- Patience keeps the door open for reconciliation. Newton cites Desmond Tutu's reflection on forgiveness and reconciliation — that you cannot have reconciliation without both repentance and forgiveness, and that anger forecloses it — to argue that patience means deferring retaliation in order to leave room for restored relationship.
- Joy is distinct from happiness. Newton distinguishes chara (spiritual joy) from circumstantial happiness, arguing that true joy is a delight in who God is rather than what God gives — and that this is why Paul could write joyfully even while imprisoned and facing execution.
- Agape love is non-transactional. Using Tim Keller's point about the cross, Newton argues that Jesus did not love people because they were lovely but in order to make them lovely — and that this fruit, love, produces in a follower of Jesus a deep security rooted not in performance but in being unconditionally loved.
FULL TRANSCRIPT
Series Recap: Paul, the Sarx, and the Holy Spirit
Rev Harry Newton: Over the last couple of weeks, we've been in a short series looking into something called the Fruit of the Spirit. If you haven't been here the last couple of weeks, that's absolutely fine. I'm going to give you a one-minute summary of what we talked about, and then we're going to look into this week's content — just so you're all on the same page.
In the text you heard read, some things were referred to as "the flesh" and "the spirit." Weird. What's he going on about? Paul is the author. Paul's a rat bag — originally called Saul. He used to go around ripping people from their homes, having them stoned to death, including children, and he'd imprison them, make them slaves. Terrible guy. Their only crime was that they were Jews who wanted to follow Jesus. Then he became a follower of Jesus himself, changed his name to Paul, and committed his life to following the way of Jesus and telling everyone about what had happened to him. With me so far? Cool.
He writes a series of letters. This particular letter was written to a series of churches in five different cities in an area called Galatia — a Roman province. And in it, he writes to them about what he calls the fruit of the Spirit.
What Is the Holy Spirit?
Now, what is the Spirit? That's his shorthand way of referring to the Holy Spirit. As Christians, we believe there's one God, but there's God the Father, God the Son, and God the Holy Spirit — three facets, or three personae, within the one, without division into three. Does that make sense? You shouldn't nod your head. You should shake your head, because it doesn't make sense. That's the point. If you're really geeky like me and you love that kind of thing, I can commend to you Thomas Aquinas' metaphysics — I've got a copy if you want it. If you don't know who Thomas Aquinas was, he was a 13th century Italian monk who thought shaving the top of his head was a good look.
The Holy Spirit is used today as a way of referring to God's tangible, real, and intimate presence with us here on earth. When Jesus ascends into heaven, he sends the Holy Spirit so that he can be with us.
Anyone heard the name Sandy Miller? A few people? If you haven't, it's fine. Sandy Miller is still alive — did you know that? He's almost 100. Sandy Miller was the Bishop of London, and before that, the vicar of a church called Holy Trinity Brompton, HTB. That's the Alpha Church, for those of you who have heard of that. When he first became the vicar there, he wanted to talk about the Holy Spirit one day, and he got up in what was a very formal English church and talked about how the Holy Spirit was God's intimate presence with us. Do you know he got a formal written warning from his bishop for using the word "intimate" in a sermon? How good is that?
His point — and he's written about it, and I remember hearing an interview with him not long ago where he laughed about it — was that it really is intimate. There's a real personal element to this. That's what the Holy Spirit does: it makes God knowable to us. So that's what Paul means when he refers to the Spirit — God's intimate, knowable presence with us in life.
The Sarx: Living Apart from God
In our reading, Paul contrasts the fruit of the Spirit with what he calls the desires of the flesh. That's a weird thing to say. What's he talking about? We unpacked this at length last week. I'm not going to redo it — if you're interested, it's on the app and you can go back and re-listen. Suffice to say, the word he uses here for the flesh is Greek: sarx, S-A-R-X. Paul uses it as a way of referring to the tendency within each and every one of us to run our lives independently of God — to try and be our own bosses, to be our own source of worth, and essentially to be our own saviour to some degree.
And what is the outcome of following the sarx? What's the fruit, as it were, of living a life on our own terms apart from God? To summarise it, Eugene Peterson — anyone heard of Eugene Peterson? If you haven't, he died recently. He was an American pastor and theologian who wrote a book called The Message, which is the Message version of the Bible. He described the fruit of following the sarx like this:
"The accumulation of mental and emotional garbage, frenzied and joyless grabs for happiness, paranoid loneliness, cutthroat competition, all-consuming yet never satisfied desire, small-minded and lopsided pursuits, and the vicious habit of depersonalizing everyone into a rival."
Does that sound like a bit of a summary of our times or what?
The Fruit of the Spirit: An Overview
Now, but, says Paul, if you're someone who follows the way of Jesus, your fruit will be the fruit of the Spirit: love, joy, peace, patience, kindness, goodness, faithfulness, gentleness, and self-control. Nine fruits.
Paul is intentionally placing a very clear contrast between two different ways of life before us. To be clear, he is not putting forward a list of how to be acceptable to God. You know that little line — "whoever lives this way will not inherit the kingdom of God"? He's not saying you have to live up to a certain moral code. He's saying the way you live, the fruit of your life, is a reflection of how you orientate your life. And if you are reflecting that fruit of the sarx, then it means you're not following God. That's why you won't inherit the kingdom of God.
His point, partly, is to say that the fruit you produce in your life says something profound about you, because it shows who or what you are following — the sarx or the Holy Spirit. Because none of us lives in a vacuum, regardless of our religious or spiritual orientation. We can all agree on that. No one lives in a vacuum. We're all being formed by something, even if it's just the algorithm — which, if it's my algorithm, it's all about airplanes. My wife tells me that means I'm autistic. I don't know if that's true.
But as we discovered last week, your life is always bearing fruit of some kind, because you're always following someone or something. The question isn't whether you're going to produce fruit of some sort in your life. It's whose fruit is it going to be.
John Stott's Three Triads
So today, what I want to do is bring together the various threads from the last few weeks on our short series on the fruit of the Spirit. And I think it would be helpful to explore what the fruit of the Spirit actually look like in life. Because some of these fruits — love, joy, peace, kindness, all those good things — at first reading, this sounds like a list of character traits, doesn't it? Some people are more patient than other people. My mum is one of the most patient people I've ever met. She's next to godliness in terms of her patience. My dad is the polar opposite. Rosie's laughing because she knows my dad quite well.
Now, they are to a degree like character traits, but not ours — they're God's characteristics. As Christians, we believe that humanity is made in the image of God. We've had that discussion before and we'll cover it again another time. But suffice to say that we are made in the image of God, so there's a degree to which some of the characteristics of God are mirrored, even if only dimly, in our own lives.
One way to conceptualise or understand the fruit of the Spirit that I've found helpful comes from a guy called John Stott. Anyone heard of John Stott? Cool. If you haven't, John Stott in 2005 was ranked among the 100 most influential people in the world by Time magazine. Not bad for an Anglican vicar. He broke the nine fruits of the Spirit into what he called three triads. The first triad relates to our relationship with God, the second to our relationship with others, and the third to our relationship with ourselves.
Love, joy, and peace depict our relationship to and with God. Patience, kindness, and goodness depict our relationship to and with others. And faithfulness, gentleness, and self-control depict our relationship with ourselves.
What I want to do is explore these ever so briefly, but in reverse order.
Triad Three: Our Relationship with Ourselves
Self-Control
I went to Greek school for five and a half years and I do not know how to speak Greek. I used to get caned every morning by my Greek teacher for mispronouncing kalimera. So if you do speak Greek and I mispronounce any of this, I'm really sorry.
The word Paul uses here for self-control is enkrateia. It carries a sense of having the capacity to hold your desires, impulses, and passions in check rather than being ruled by them. And that's the direct opposite of what Paul referred to as the works of the sarks — that selfish nature, the tendency within each of us to try and live our life independent of God. In his list of the works of the sarks, Paul mentions things like drunkenness, sexual immorality, and outbursts of anger — all of which depict a person whose inner life is run by a lack of enkrateia, a lack of self-control, a lack of the ability to hold their impulses in check.
What's interesting is that Paul isn't referring to self-control here as a form of self-generated willpower. You ever met those people who are ridiculously self-controlled? And they're kind of annoying? He's not talking about just having better willpower. What he's saying is that he places this fruit of the Spirit last, and his point is that true mastery over the self isn't produced simply through having deeper resolution or grit or following enough motivational accounts on social media or making New Year's resolutions. It's actually a result of having the Holy Spirit at work within you.
And so this fruit, self-control, depicts a follower of Jesus who is able to keep their inner passions in check because of the presence of God in their life.
Gentleness
The second fruit in this triad is gentleness. The word he uses here is praotēs. It often gets misinterpreted because of the implications of our word "gentle." Gentle — what do you think of? You think of a child when they're being nice, not when they're being horrid. Or you think of lambs when they're not being gross — the farmers over here know what I'm talking about.
But what it means here, this word praotēs, is something quite different. It carries this sense of being the opposite of self-absorption, which if you think about it is one of the most common ways the sarks materialises in our world today. Because we all have a tendency within us to centre our lives around our will, our comfort, our vibe, our mood rather than God's. I would argue we live in the most rampantly individualistic society in the history of the planet, even compared to the ancient Romans. We have a society and an economy which is based around the fulfilment of personal desire.
And so this fruit, gentleness, depicts a follower of Jesus who has traded the throne of self-absorption for a posture of surrender to the will of God in their life. And when you think about it, that is incredibly counter-cultural, because everything around us says to centre your life on your will, your comfort, and your desires. But as the fruit of the Spirit grows in someone's heart, their self-absorption will naturally fade and their gentleness and openness to God will grow.
Faithfulness
The third and final fruit in this triad is faithfulness. The word used here is pistis. Anyone heard of Tim Keller? Bit of a hero of mine — he died not that long ago. He makes the point that pistis, or faithfulness, is the opposite of fickleness, which if you think about it is a defining characteristic of a life run by the sarks — a life that shifts loyalties and commitments depending on what serves us in the moment, or on who happens to be watching.
But here's the thing about our inherent fickleness as humans: it comes from somewhere. Have you ever met someone who's really fickle? I think we're all prone to being a bit fickle at times, and it comes from within, from a fractured self. Freud talked a lot about this — we're not going to get into Freud right now, but he had a point to a degree. Which is why I think we're prone to projecting one version of ourselves in public and yet another in private.
Pistis, on the other hand, encompasses the sense of a settled, undivided self, and it's a characteristic of God himself. We hear about it throughout scripture. Scripture consistently affirms that God is faithful — not because it benefits God, but because of who he is. If you know the Old Testament, you know the Israelites are stuffing it up every five minutes. Things go bad for them, they fall out of favour, they do something dumb — but who comes chasing after them and pulls them back into right relationship? It's God. Not because God needs them, but because God made them a promise that he would never be unfaithful. So despite their unfaithfulness, he is always faithful.
So when the Holy Spirit produces faithfulness in someone, what's actually being formed is an undivided self. This fruit, faithfulness, depicts a follower of Jesus whose interior truly matches their exterior, and vice versa.
So that's the first triad as John Stott put it — faithfulness, gentleness, and self-control shaping our relationship within ourselves.
Triad Two: Our Relationship with Others
That brings us to the second triad: patience, kindness, and goodness, and how these influence and depict our relationships with others. We're going in reverse order, so we start with goodness.
Goodness
The word used here is agathōsynē. What a great word. Now, it's about more than just being nice to people. You ever met someone who's just really, really nice? This goes beyond that. It carries a sense of generosity of spirit towards others, which materialises as a desire and willingness to go far more than social convention would ever require of you.
Let's be honest — we live in a nice, polite society, most of us. We say the right things, we smile nicely, we go to dinner parties and make small talk, and it's all lovely, particularly when there's good cheese. But this is about going beyond what social convention would expect of you.
And it's actually the opposite of envy, which Paul listed amongst the works of the sarks — that underlying desire to live a life dedicated to self. Because while envy begrudges others for what they have, true goodness does the reverse: it wants others to have more, and then it acts on that desire. Where envy shrinks us spiritually inward, goodness pushes us outward into acts of generosity to those around us, even those who don't deserve it.
You ever been kind to someone who didn't deserve it? You ever had the opportunity to stick the knife in — or to be nice instead? Honestly, it can be tempting to stick the knife in. But the fruit of the Spirit is goodness, and to will the good of the other, even if they don't deserve it.
And so this fruit, goodness, depicts a follower of Jesus who is genuinely glad to see others flourish, and then backs that gladness up with generous action.
Kindness
That brings us to the second and middle fruit in this triad, kindness. The word used here is chrēstotēs. It describes a tenderheartedness that puts others at ease, and it's the direct opposite of the harshness that the sarks produces within us.
When applied to God, the same word — kindness — describes how he treats people who feel like they don't measure up, the ones that polite company and religion push to the margins. What God did through Jesus was step into our mess to rescue us from ourselves. And that is God's kindness in its truest and fullest form. That's why Paul tells us elsewhere that all believers should clothe themselves in kindness. Because to be kind to one another isn't just a nice feeling — it's an essential ingredient of love. And like love, it only really exists if you put it into action.
And so this fruit, kindness, depicts a follower of Jesus who treats others the way that God treats them — with goodness and kindness and love, even when they don't deserve it.
Patience
The third and final fruit in this triad is patience. The word here is makrothymia. How cool a word is that? It encompasses this idea of deferring anger when we're being provoked and refusing to retaliate against those who have done us wrong. And again, it's got a direct opposite in Paul's list of the sarks — it's the opposite of a fit of anger, that tendency to lash out and retaliate the moment we're offended or hurt. I'm sure you know that feeling.
One of the key reasons Paul shares elsewhere in scripture — actually in 1 Thessalonians chapter 5 — for exercising patience is that deferring retaliation always leaves room for reconciliation. God deferred judgment on the human race so that Jesus could come and pay the price on our behalf so we could be reconciled to God. And we are called to do the same to others.
Anyone know who Desmond Tutu is? Yeah, cool. Post-Rwandan genocide, he went there, and I remember hearing an interview with him — I actually met him briefly. And he said this thing: you can have forgiveness without repentance, and you can have repentance without forgiveness, but you can't have reconciliation without both. And reconciliation also can't happen if you have anger in your heart. It's not wrong, is it? It's true.
And so this fruit, patience, depicts a follower of Jesus who would rather leave the door open for reconciliation with their enemies than slam it shut. Why? Because they themselves have been reconciled to God.
Triad One: Our Relationship with God
And that brings us to our third and final triad: love, joy, and peace, and how they influence and depict our relationship with God himself.
Peace
First of all, peace. The word used here is eirēnē. In essence, it's a confidence and a rest in the wisdom and the control of God rather than our own. And it results in freedom from the anxiety and worry that comes from trying to hold everything together ourselves. It is the direct opposite of what happens when the sarks takes the wheel in your life, which results in a constant scrambling to manage your life and retain some semblance of control.
Peace is not the absence of struggle or challenge in your life. It is a deep-rooted confidence in the goodness of God and a belief that he is in charge of the world despite our circumstances.
And so this fruit, peace, depicts a follower of Jesus who has stopped trying to run their own life and instead rests in God, who is actually deeply in control of everything.
Joy
That brings us to our second-to-last fruit, joy. Chara is the word — I apologise if my pronunciation is wrong. It's not the same as happiness. Happiness kind of comes and goes with your vibe, right? I had a really good coffee this morning at Bohemian Bakery — they don't usually make great coffee, but this morning it was good. My happiness was quite high for a short bit, but then it went down when something else happened. So that's not joy in the true sense.
Chara, joy, is a delight in God himself — not for what God gives us, but simply in who God is. That's why Paul, our author, could write about the joy of God even when he was in prison. And later on, when he was taken to Rome and held in quite distressing circumstances and eventually executed for his faith, we're told that throughout that time he continually rejoiced in the goodness of God.
The sarks roots joy in things that change — our comfort, our success, things going well for us. Chara, divine spiritual joy, on the other hand, roots itself in one thing that can never change: the goodness of God.
And so this fruit, joy, depicts a follower of Jesus whose delight in God runs so deep that not even a lethal situation can kill it. And just as an aside, from a personal perspective — you know, like when you've got a family member who's really sick and they're not getting better and you can't do anything about it, and it makes you angry and upset — you can still trust, still have deep-rooted proper joy in the goodness of God. Because your joy, my joy, does not rise and fall on our circumstances or the circumstances of our family members.
Love
And that brings us to our final fruit, love — agape. Now, if you've been in church for more than five minutes, you would have heard many, many sermons on agape. Don't worry, we're not going to do that. But what I will say is this: agape is a specific type of love, and it's different from romantic love. Because romantic love to some degree is transactional, right?
Like, you meet someone who's cute. The only way I could get Amy to talk to me was to pick a fight with her. I saw her, I tried saying hi, and she blanked me. I knew she was a teacher and I knew she was raging left-wing. So I went up and said, "Man, John Key's government's doing some great reforms around education." Man, it triggered her. It's awesome, right? And she talked to me.
Now, here's the thing. I met her and I felt she was lovable. And over time, she decided she got over my bad politics and decided that I was lovable too. We shared a bond. We fell in love. We got married. Life is good. It's beautiful when it's life-giving. Being married to Amy is an amazing blessing. But there is a degree to which even your deepest romantic love is transactional to some degree, because there are parameters around it — faithfulness within a marriage, for one.
So Paul here is not talking about that type of love. Paul is getting at something a little bit different with his use of agape. And this is where a point that Tim Keller makes about Jesus on the cross is really pertinent. He said this: Jesus did not die for people who had earned it or deserved it. Jesus died for people who actively betrayed, denied, and abandoned him — and yet he did it anyway. His point is that Jesus did not love you because you are lovely. He loves you to make you lovely.
And that's why God's love is a different type of love from what we experience in life, even in our most healthy relationships. Because it doesn't wait for someone to become worth loving. Jesus loves first, and then the value of the one who is loved flows out of that.
And so this fruit, love, depicts a follower of Jesus who stands before God knowing that they were loved long before they had anything to offer him. And from that, this fruit depicts someone who is deeply secure in who they are, because they know deep down that they are loved simply because they are. It's not contingent on anything.
Closing: Whose Fruit Is It?
Today's sermon has been a bit more of a lecture — boom, boom, boom, boom, boom. Hope it was interesting. If you got lost but found something in it helpful, or you want to go back to it, you can get the app. Go to the journal notes and I've put it all there, including some personal questions for you to consider this week and how you can apply this to your life.
That's the fruit of the Spirit. Love, joy, and peace shaping our relationship with God. Patience, kindness, and goodness shaping our relationship with others. Faithfulness, gentleness, and self-control shaping our relationship within ourselves. Each one is the direct opposite of what the sarks — the selfish nature — produces when we try to run our own lives, and each one continues to grow in us as we stay close to Jesus.
As we discussed last week, there are three key ways you can stay close to Jesus: read your Bible, pray, and worship.
And so the question I want to leave you with today isn't whether you're bearing fruit. You already are. The question for you is: whose fruit is it? The sarks or the Holy Spirit? And I'll be honest — if you're really honest with yourself, it'll be a mixture, and that's okay. But if you want to see more of the fruit of the Spirit in your life, pray. Challenge those assumptions within yourself and be open to the promptings of God. Cultivate a heart that is open to the Holy Spirit through your prayer, your scripture, and your worship, and watch yourself be changed into a new person over the next five, ten, fifteen, twenty-plus years.