Candace Owens podcast covers nationwide tech outages, Mossad visit to DC, and Tyler Robinson trial evidence dispute
Solo presenter Baron Coleman hosts the Candace podcast, covering a wave of infrastructure outages, a visit by the Mossad director to Washington, and a legal dispute over bullet fragment evidence in the Tyler Robinson murder trial.
Summary
A wave of major technology and infrastructure outages that struck the United States across a single week in mid-November opens the episode, with host Coleman arguing that official explanations of routine system upgrades are not credible and that the timing — coinciding with an unscheduled visit to Washington by the Mossad director — is not coincidental. of a series of major technology and infrastructure outages that struck the United States across a single week in mid-November, arguing that official explanations of routine system upgrades are not credible and that the timing — coinciding with an unscheduled visit to Washington by the Mossad director — is not coincidental. He connects the outages to Israeli pressure on the Trump administration to resume the war against Iran, and dismisses a CNN report about an alleged Iranian dirty bomb plot in Washington as fabricated intelligence designed to drag the US back into conflict. In the second major segment, Coleman examines a legal dispute in the Tyler Robinson capital murder case, in which the FBI is blocking defense access to bullet fragment evidence on the grounds that its internal quality assurance manual prohibits outside observers in its laboratory — a policy Coleman argues is stricter than the ISO and ANAB standards the FBI cites, and which he contends could result in the destruction of potentially exculpatory evidence before the defense can examine it.
Key Takeaways
FULL TRANSCRIPT
Nationwide Infrastructure Outages — Overview
Baron Coleman: Welcome in. We've got a lot to talk about today. The world appears to be on fire and our government is telling us it may actually get worse before it gets better, if it ever gets better. We're going to run through a lot of this today, and we've got some updates on the Tyler Robinson trial. The defense is maybe getting the short end of the stick yet again. There's a whole lot to talk about.
I think we sort of naively get into this mindset that everything's going to be the way it's always been. We understand things sort of arc towards progress. If I look back towards my childhood, there were no cell phones, no wireless connections to anything because there was no internet, and the world somehow managed to get by. I actually saw a really interesting thread on Twitter the other day where somebody said, "I know that people used to do something in the office, but without a cell phone, without a computer — what actually happened in there?" And then there were older people who would jump in the comments and describe what happened in an office setting long before the days of a laptop on every desk, long before the days of a cell phone in every pocket.
We have to understand the dangers that come along with progress. We have to understand the ways we can safeguard ourselves on a forward-going basis. So what we talk about tonight — I'm not trying to scare anyone. If it seems a little frightening, that's just part of life, that's part of where we are now. Put everything in that context as we go through tonight's show, because there are some weird and wild things happening out there and they seem to be accelerating very, very quickly. I'm really not 100% sure where it goes, where it ends, or why it's happening. But what we can do is analyze what we see.
We'll start by letting you know that literally everything is breaking right now. There's a website online called Down Detector. If you go to Down Detector, you can see charts and graphs of different reports of user outages. Down Detector has been a lifeline the last week or so because everything seems to be down.
Last Thursday — that's November 12th, just a few days ago — we got this headline: Microsoft identifies issues leading to global Outlook outage. It was actually a lot more than just Outlook, but Outlook was the thing most people recognized was down. Microsoft has become, since the 1980s, almost indispensable in most office settings. The vast majority of the business and government world uses, in some form, Outlook, Microsoft Teams, Microsoft Word. All of this stuff was down last week and nobody really had an explanation for why. They come out and always give you some sort of acute explanation — oh, it's nothing to worry about. And in an isolated situation, maybe it was nothing to worry about.
Then we woke up Friday morning and everything was progressing nicely until we got a headline about the FAA ground stop. It's a pretty crazily worded message: extraordinary circumstances, reasons of safety. All aircraft operators, by order of the federal government, were essentially ground stopped — get on the ground and stay on the ground until further notice. It led to widespread havoc going into the weekend. There were sports games going on all over the country, and that's where a lot of people noticed it because your favorite sports team might not make the game on Saturday or Sunday. It was chaotic. They come out afterwards and give you a little explanation — well, it was really nothing to worry about. And you're like, wait a minute, that's what Microsoft said yesterday, and it disrupted daily life for millions and millions of people around the globe.
Then the following day, we get this FAA ground stop and they're telling us, "Hey, nothing to worry about. Just a routine upgrade that went awry." I can't help but notice — and we'll talk about this again in the next segment — that on Friday there was an unscheduled visit to Washington DC from the director of the Mossad.
Context: The Iran War and the Election
Now, keep in mind the context of where all of this is happening. Just a couple of weeks ago, the Republicans got their butts kicked in the elections. Absolutely annihilated. And what was the issue? The overriding issue was the war in Iran. There's no question about it. Every exit poll said the same thing. This was a major issue that the vast majority of voters showed up with on their mind, and the vast majority were not in favor of the war in Iran. They sent a very clear and crystal clear message to the president of the United States and Congress: stop this nonsense. We're not in favor of it. We don't want you using our tax dollars to do it and we don't want you using our blood to do it. We don't want to send our men and women to die over there. Knock this off.
Well, the director of the Mossad comes to town and everything starts to break. We'll talk more about that in a second.
The Workday Payroll Outage
Then on Friday, not to be outdone by the FAA, there was a HR payroll company called Workday. Workday outage locked employees and firms out of pay and benefits on a Friday. Keep in mind, a lot of firms pay every Friday, or every other Friday, or the last Friday of the month, or the middle Friday. Friday is a big payroll day. If you've ever worked in a bank, you know that's the day the lines are long.
Customers at Target, Walmart, Charles Schwab, NASA's Jet Propulsion Laboratory — these are big companies that use Workday payroll, and all of them were locked out of their pay and their benefits. They didn't know whether they got paid. That's a scary thing. A lot of people work paycheck to paycheck. I saw a statistic one time that like 60 or 70% of people in the United States couldn't scrape together $1,000 on 48 hours' notice. So if you can't get paid, there's that old expression — it's a recession until you lose your job, and then it's a depression. Well, if you can't get paid, it's a depression. This stoppage caused a depression for a lot of workers.
The weekend was fine. Noteworthy — the weekend was fine. There weren't a lot of outages reported over the weekend.
Monday's Banking Outage
Then yesterday, Monday, we were hit with this headline: A major banking outage linked to Chase impacted Wells Fargo and Bank of America. Now we're getting down to the nitty-gritty. Now you're messing with people's money directly. It's one thing to say you may not get paid today. It's another thing to say when you go to the ATM it won't work, when you go inside and talk to the teller they can't pull up your banking information. Was my money secure? We don't know. When will I know? We don't know that either.
These are the types of things that make people really cautious, really worried, frankly. How many people rely on the ability to use a debit card or a credit card to make a transaction? What if it gets declined? You know you have a balance, but the bank's not working right now. Well, go put all your stuff back on the Walmart shelf. We'll be back to you later.
The head of the Mossad is in town still.
Websites Subverted, United Airlines Down
Then, not to be outdone, we have other major outages from yesterday. Here's a headline from Reuters: Popular websites subverted in bid to steal crypto and target iPhone users. These are some of the world's most viewed websites, including those belonging to Zoom, HSBC, Equifax, CNN, Salesforce, and IKEA. They were all subverted in an effort to steal cryptocurrency and to infect iPhones. If you showed up to the website on your iPhone, you might get a malicious JavaScript added to your phone. This affected 178 organizations. This is a real issue.
Still on Monday, back to the airline industry — not the FAA, this time we're talking directly to airline systems themselves. We get this tweet from United Airlines: "We sincerely apologize for the inconvenience. We're aware of the widespread system outage. Our teams are working hard to get things back up and running as soon as possible." If you can't get on your plane and you miss your meeting or don't make your job interview, you can see the problem. These things start to stack up on people.
United comes out and says there's no indication this is any kind of outage due to cybersecurity-related issues. Well, no indication doesn't mean it's not.
Are They Telling the Truth?
I would pause here before we go to the next day. Let's say these were all cybersecurity issues. Let's say there was a hack that got into Microsoft Outlook and the Microsoft Suite. Let's say there was a hack that got into the FAA, a federal agency that controls the safety of tens of millions of people in the air every day. Let's say there was a hack that got into a payroll company that prevented people from seeing their benefits or getting their pay for the day. Let's say there was a hack that got into major banks — not your local community bank, I'm talking massive banks that affect tens of millions of customers. Let's say there was a hack that got into these websites to steal crypto and target iPhone users. Let's say there was a hack that went directly after a major airline carrier, I think the second largest in the country.
Are they going to come out and tell you that? Be honest. Are they going to come out and tell you that we can't stop what's happening? What would be the result of that? You'd probably have runs on banks, runs on grocery stores. You'd probably have people running to the gas station filling up their fuel and getting a nationwide fuel shortage. You have to understand the motivation built into the system to lie to every single person watching the news, looking at the X feeds, reading the headlines. There's a tremendous motivation to lie to you. And that's not going to change as this stuff continues piling up.
Tuesday: NSA Network Down, Hockey Federation Hacked, Norway Energy Attack, Apple Outage
Because just today we get even more problems, this time from the intelligence community. Here's the headline from CNN: Highly classified US national security communications network goes down. Sources say this is a network communication system used within the NSA, and there were six people cited. They said the network, called NSANet, allows employees to communicate classified information internally. And here's the throwaway line — think of the motivation — no evidence of a cyber attack. Sources said it's a weird way to word that. No evidence. They're not telling you it's not a cyber attack. They're just telling you right now they're not going to show you the evidence of a cyber attack.
It's not done today. This is just Tuesday of the week. All this just started last Thursday.
They're even going after minor league hockey. The International Ice Hockey Federation was the target of a cyber attack. The IIHF didn't get the memo that they're supposed to lie to their customers like everybody else is doing. They came out and said, "We strongly condemn these actions and are taking all necessary steps to make sure minor league hockey gets back up and running." Well, if they're going to attack minor league hockey, do you think there's anything that's safe?
It's not just minor league hockey. We have a cyber attack out of Norway. Norway's Ecuador detects cyber attack on IT systems — operations unaffected. This is a giant energy provider in Norway.
And not to be outdone — what's the biggest animal in tech right now? I've got two Apple devices on my desk as we speak. Apple is now hit with an outage: iCloud, Apple Pay, and more of their services. Apple reported outages across several of its platforms on Tuesday, including iCloud, Apple Pay, and the App Store. The company's system status page as of 2:30 p.m. Eastern time showed full or partial outages affecting platforms like the iCloud website, Apple's business services, on-device Apple Care support, and more.
Pattern Recognition and the AI Threat
Guys, this is not something that can be ignored. We've been lied to for a long time. We've been lied to about JFK's assassination, RFK's assassination, Martin Luther King's assassination, Malcolm X's assassination. Then we get lied to on things like 9/11. We get lied to constantly. We were lied to about weapons of mass destruction — remember, we're going to go in there, we're going to be greeted as liberators, right, Donald Rumsfeld? Right, Dick Cheney? We get lied to all the time. We've been lied to by our government, by these massive corporations that install our governments frankly. And I don't think it's any different now. I don't think they're being honest with you about these being routine upgrades that have gone awry, about old copper wires that just need a little more money to replace. No. It's too much. One thing is a random occurrence. Twice is a coincidence. Three times is a pattern. Ten times — they're lying to you.
Some of them are being honest because they didn't get the message, like the energy company out of Norway, like the minor league hockey federation. They'll just be honest and say, "Yeah, we got hacked. Not much we can do about it. We're trying to fix it." Everybody else is winking and nodding and playing the game.
The question is — is this what we've been fearing with the AI revolution? We have a headline out of TechCrunch: The FBI says Rex AI open-source hacking tool has been used to breach networks in under three hours. So they invented a tool they told us was necessary. We had to invest all these billions, maybe trillions of dollars into this AI revolution because if we don't, China's going to beat us to it. And we invent this tool and all of a sudden it's being used to cause mass chaos against us. Make it so you can't get your paycheck. Make it so you can't get your money out of your bank. Can't get your energy in Norway. Can't play minor league hockey. What are we doing?
It seems to me if the government is not working for the betterment of its people, it's not working at all. And right now it does not appear to be working for the betterment of its people.
Here's a headline from Google about their outage: Google AI threat tracker — agentic threat activity crosses a significant threshold. It goes on to say: "As threat actors increasingly move beyond basic prompting to deploying autonomous multi-agent frameworks, automated vulnerability exploitation pipelines, and alternative monetization schemes like LLM jacking, the adversarial AI landscape has reached a critical inflection point."
Well, I'd say so. Seems like it's more than a critical inflection point. Seems like it's crossing into real-world trauma.
"In this update, Google Threat Intelligence Group and Mandiant examine how adversaries across the cybercrime, espionage, and information operation spectrum are operationalizing generative AI to compress attack timelines, scale operations, and execute multi-stage intrusions at machine speed."
In other words, ladies and gentlemen, water flows downhill. Water still flows downhill, and it finds all the cracks. Crooks have been around forever. I don't know why they couldn't have seen this coming. There's the old joke about Jesse James — why'd you rob all those banks? Well, that's where the money is. There have always been crooks. There have always been people who break the law, people who try to steal, people who try to hold things for ransom or hostage. This is a normal part of human society. I have no idea why we thought this stuff would only be used for good.
You know, when you elect somebody and say, "Yeah, give them all the power, let them just go crazy" — well, guess what? Your party may be out of power next time and now you've set the precedent. Water flows downhill. It always finds the cracks. This technology, if it can be used for good, will be used for bad. And I think it is being used for bad. And it's accelerating at a rapid pace.
Bill Gates Predicted This — Eight Days Ago
The question is who is doing it. But I want to pause and go back to before all this chaos started. Just November 9th, last week, eight days ago. Bill Gates sat down with CBS and he looked into the future and thought, "What's it going to take for the American people to accept this technological dominance over their life and finally yield to us, the billionaire class who know better?" Here's what Bill Gates said would be the breaking point.
Bill Gates: "Well, one thing that's clear is if you have a big cyber attack that caused a lot of problems, then people will say, 'Okay, they were right. The people who were talking about that were right.' So it may be that we have to suffer a few of the negatives before we'll respond as fully as we should. Fortunately, those aren't civilization-ending. They're bad."
CBS Interviewer: "I mean, if you hack Fidelity or Vanguard and much of the world's trillion-dollar retirement nest egg, that would be a pretty big event."
Bill Gates: "Well, you could create uncertainty in cases like that. And so being ready, trying to make sure we do the things and avoid any negative incidents. But assuming we fall short of that, then when some of the negatives start to emerge, you have very concrete ideas in place. So people say, 'Okay, you're right. We don't want that to happen again.' So I know that getting people into this dialogue is worthwhile, even though the risk that we'll allow a few events to happen is very high."
CBS Interviewer: "So in other words, what it's going to take for us as a country and a world to tackle this is not just a 12-page essay from Bill Gates. It could be a catastrophe."
Bill Gates: "That's fair. It could take a catastrophe."
Baron Coleman: You've been bad, ladies and gentlemen. You've been bad. You've not been listening to Bill Gates — the guy who flew to the island all the time. You've not been listening to Bill Gates, the guy whose wife left him because he flew to the island. And it might take a catastrophe, hopefully a catastrophe short of civilizational collapse.
Notice how he breezed past the fact that they might hack into everybody's retirement and drain all their accounts and you might be broke and penniless and out on the streets. He just sort of — well, it might happen. I don't think Bill's worried about losing his hundreds of billions of dollars. And he's not too worried about you losing your maybe hundred grand you saved up for retirement to supplement your Social Security on your way out. Maybe you hoped to leave $50,000 or $100,000 to your kids and that gets zapped in a hack attack one day. He doesn't really care much about that. What really bothers him is you're not listening to him.
Who the hell is Bill Gates? You realize in all of human history, Bill Gates would have died in infancy because he's a squirmy little rat. He just happened to be born at a time when some squirmy little rat could become one of the richest people on earth and one of the most powerful people who ever lived. But because he just hit the chronological lottery, we now have to yield to his every wish. And if you don't, well, there's going to be hell to pay. Well, guess what? We may be paying hell right now. We may be seeing hell playing out right now as system after system keeps going down and they keep telling you, "Oh, nothing to worry about. Nothing to see here."
The Director of National Intelligence Responds
The director of national intelligence, a guy named Tulsi Gabbard, comes out and says, "Also, no evidence of a cyber attack here. Take it from us. We would never lie to you."
Tulsi Gabbard: "Let me tell you what this is not — and this is to the best of our capabilities looking across the federal government and talking to our private sector partners. We do not see the indicia of a coordinated cyber attack. Let me just be clear about that. And we do not see the indicia of state-sponsored activity here. And we can be fairly confident in that because we know those things exist and we've been looking for them in the past. Let me tell you what we think this is, and we think it is with confidence. Lots of institutions, because these vulnerabilities have been identified, are patching. They're taking their systems down. They're upgrading them. They're putting patches in place. When you do that across sophisticated systems and you bring them back online — as we all know, if we've worked in business, when you take your system down and upgrade it over the weekend, people say it's going to come back on at 2:00 a.m. on a Sunday. Well, sometimes it doesn't come back on till 4 or 5:00 a.m. on a Sunday. This is being done on a much larger scale because everybody — and it's a good news story — everybody recognizes it's time to upgrade their systems. And as they upgrade them, they're not coming back as expected in all cases. And in some cases, systems have to hand off to other systems, and those handoffs are not coming back as expected. But this is just an upgrade and patching of systems. And looking very diligently across the landscape, we are not seeing this as a cyber attack incident."
Baron Coleman: I don't believe you. I think you're lying to us. Just like you lied to us about 9/11. Just like you lied to us about weapons of mass destruction. Just like you lied to us about every major political assassination the last 60-plus years. I think you're lying to us. I just don't believe you that everybody decided all at once to run out and do patches on their systems, roll out these patches within the same three or four business days, and they all failed.
Notice all the hedging language he used. "We don't see evidence of a coordinated attack." Well, do you see evidence of a non-coordinated attack? "We don't see evidence of state-sponsored attacks." Well, do you see evidence of non-state-sponsored attacks? "We're fairly confident." Well, are you very, very confident? Are you certain? No. Hedge, hedge, hedge, hedge, hedge. In my opinion — lie, lie, lie, lie, lie.
You don't get to get away with it forever. If what we've experienced on Thursday and Friday and Monday and Tuesday rolls into Wednesday and Thursday and Friday of this week, I think I'm right and you're wrong.
The Mossad Visit and the Iran War
When we come back, we'll look at maybe a visit from a foreign — not going to say dignitary — foreign person and whether or not that has anything to do with what we're experiencing right now.
Let's put it all back in context again. I don't want to lose sight of the context in which all this is happening. You've got to go back a couple of weeks and remember that the number one issue going into the election was the Iran war, and it wasn't even close. One of the reasons people were against the Iran war is because it felt like we were being dragged into it against our wills. It felt like Israel was pushing us into a war that our people did not want to be in. And it felt like meet the new boss, same as the old boss. Trump's falling for the same thing that Barack Obama fell for, that Joe Biden fell for, that George Bush fell for — just on and on and on.
So after the election loss, a lot of public officials and a lot of the talking heads — frankly, a lot of the neocons who were in favor of the Iran war — realized on the Republican side, hey, wait a minute, that just caused us to give the Democrats 56 of the 100 United States Senate seats. Momentum is not at our side. They lost the House. They lost all kinds of governorships. State houses fell. It was just a bloodbath for Republicans all over the country. And a lot of the people who were in favor of the Iran war said, "Well, maybe it's just not worth it. Maybe we need to pull back on this." So the rhetoric starts ramping up. JD Vance, the vice president of the United States, even comes out and says, "Hey, maybe the Iran war is something that's not a great idea."
So we get an unscheduled visit Friday here in the United States. David Barnea — he's the director of the Mossad — visits Washington for talks with CIA director John Ratcliffe. Here's the headline: Mossad meets with the CIA. Scoop: Israeli spy chief in DC as Netanyahu presses Trump to resume war.
Ain't that interesting? Everybody in the United States seems to be on the same page, singing from the same hymnal for the first time in two years — maybe we shouldn't go to war in Iran. Maybe we should pull back on this deal. Maybe we should just declare a win or declare a loss. I don't care. Just get the hell out of there. Get the oil flowing again. Bring gas prices back down. Get stability back in the region, kind of like it was nine months or a year ago when everything didn't seem to be falling apart over there.
Here is how Axios put it: "The director of Israeli spy agency Mossad is in Washington Friday for talks with senior Trump administration officials about the war in Iran, according to three sources with knowledge of the matter. Here's why it matters: the visit by David Barnea, one of Benjamin Netanyahu's closest confidants, comes as the Israeli prime minister is pressing President Trump to resume the war against Iran. He's meeting with John Ratcliffe, the director of the CIA. He's expected to travel to Miami to meet White House Envoy Steve Witkoff, one of the sources said."
Well, what happens in this situation? How do you talk the United States back into a war when we just had a nationwide vote on this war pretty much? That Tuesday election was basically a nationwide referendum on our policy of support for Israel and engaging in foreign wars on behalf of the political state of Israel. And the nation spoke largely with one loud, resounding, yelling, screaming voice: no, stop, we don't want it, we don't want anymore.
So how would you respond if you were Israel and you were dying to have the United States prosecute this war on your behalf? You're not willing to do it yourself. Obviously, you need the big brother, the United States, to come in and do it for you. Well, you would probably try to make our life hell. If I had to guess, you would start applying pressure. You might have leaks coming out of Washington about certain officials. Well, if that won't work, maybe you threaten those officials. Well, we don't want blood on our hands, though. Maybe we threaten those officials and we claim it's those dirty Iranians.
The Dirty Bomb Story
Here's a headline from CNN just yesterday: US intel indicates Iran developing plans to potentially detonate a dirty bomb in Washington. A dirty bomb — for those of you that don't know what a dirty bomb is, too young to remember the early parts after 9/11 — this is when you take nuclear material, radioactive material, and you don't detonate it as a nuclear device. You just put it around a conventional explosive device and you detonate it, and it in theory spreads a cloud of dangerous radiation around the area. Then it gets carried by the wind, downwind, and it affects a whole bunch of innocent civilians. That's the nature of a dirty bomb.
But I have to ask you a question. Why in the hell would Iran do that? It's like me walking into a bar and poking Mike Tyson in the eyes. How's that going to end for me? Probably not well. Iran's kind of in a pretty good spot right now, if we're being honest. Why would they provoke the United States? Doesn't make any sense.
Guess what? I think they're lying to you again. This intelligence seems to be coming from the Israelis. Who has more motivation to provoke the United States into a massive response against Iran — Iran or Israel? It's a no-brainer. It's an absolute no-brainer. You have to look at this in that light. You have to ask who benefits. You have to ask who would get destroyed and who wants that person destroyed. Does Iran want to destroy itself? Well, the best way to do that would be to detonate a dirty bomb in Washington DC. Well, if someone else wanted to destroy Iran, the best way to do that would be to detonate a dirty bomb in Washington DC and blame it on Iran.
Here's a clip from CNN discussing this plan.
CNN Anchor: "We have some breaking news for you in our world lead now and a CNN exclusive. New US intelligence indicates that the government of Iran is developing plans to target senior Trump administration officials by detonating a so-called dirty bomb or a chemical weapon here in the nation's capital of Washington DC. This as officials in the Trump administration continue to debate whether Iran can or will attempt to do this, according to seven US officials. Let me bring in CNN's Katie Bo Lillis who has the latest reporting. And Katie Bo, this is disturbing. What more can you tell us about this alleged planning by Tehran?"
Katie Bo Lillis: "Yeah. So what US intelligence officials are picking up on here is the planning effort. They view this as an effort by Iran to give itself this option to take this step if they choose to do so. It's not an indicator, at least right now, of an imminent attack, but officials are still taking this very, very seriously. It sparked a real flurry of contingency planning efforts here in Washington. One of the things you're seeing officials responding to is intelligence collected by the intelligence community of Iranian chatter talking about this potential plan and the way that they might be able to carry it out. So again, something officials are taking very, very seriously even as there is some debate about how mature the planning is — whether or not this is something that they either can or will do."
Baron Coleman: You know, Iran's been two weeks away from getting a nuclear weapon since like 400 AD, according to these same sources, according to the same intelligence officials. This is a lie. I do not believe you. Just like I concluded the last segment — I don't believe you. You can only pull the same trick so many times and people are going to sit back eventually and say, "No, no, that's not true. That's not happening."
Anyone who tries to look you in the eye and tell you this is true, that it's in Iran's interest to launch a dirty bomb attack in our nation's capital — they'll lie to you about anything. If they tell you water is wet, check it out. If they tell you the sun is hot and bright, don't believe them. They will lie to you about anything if they'll tell you that. There's nobody who should believe such a foolish story. Nobody.
I don't understand why we allow these media outlets to continue to push these stories and we don't hold them to account. This has been decades — CNN has been lying on behalf of the government when they want you to go along with something that's just not true and not in your best interest. Notice it was CNN that got the NSA leak. CNN gets the story about the dirty bomb.
Guys, it's not true. It's just not true. It's designed to scare you. It's designed to whip you back in shape. And I do believe, as we opened this segment, I 100% believe all of this is related. The cyber attacks, the hardware shutdowns, the upgrades that aren't working — I believe all of this goes back to that visit from Friday to Sunday from the director of the Mossad to CIA director John Ratcliffe. I just do. And nothing's going to change my mind on that. Period. End of story.
Tyler Robinson Trial — The Bullet Fragment Evidence Dispute
When we get back, I want to tell you about what's going on in the case of Utah versus Tyler Robinson, because there's a little trickery afoot, I'm afraid, from the state. It involves the FBI. It involves our federal government. And in my opinion, if it's not called out and if the judge doesn't hold these people accountable and do the right thing here, it's a very worrisome sign for the future of this case.
Tyler Robinson is sitting on trial for his life. If Tyler Robinson loses the case, there's a very real chance he will lose his life. It's a sober responsibility when the state tries somebody for the death penalty. Every stop must be pulled out to ensure that guy gets a fair trial. There's no second chance once you pull the plug on someone's life. There's no going back and saying, "Oops, we got the wrong answer. We did it to the wrong guy." So we have to make sure we get the right answer. If Tyler Robinson's convicted, everyone needs to go to bed that night and say, "He got a fair trial." You might not agree with the outcome, but you need to agree with the fact that the trial was conducted in a fair manner.
Part of having a fair trial is having an opportunity to look at the evidence. When you go to trial, you get an opportunity to confront the witnesses against you. You can cross-examine them. You can present witnesses in support of your position. You can present evidence. You can examine the other side's evidence. Well, is that happening in this case?
There's a key piece of evidence in this case, and there's a dispute over this evidence. There are legal filings going back and forth. The judge is going to have a hearing on this in the middle of January, coming up in just a couple of months. This goes back to a dispute that's more than a year old by now.
When the state examined Charlie Kirk's body, the story goes, they retrieved from the body at least a bullet jacket fragment and four fragments of a bullet. That's the minimum we know they got out. There's some testimony at the preliminary hearing that there might have been as many as seven fragments. We don't know where those other three fragments are or whether they ever existed at all. Maybe she misspoke. Maybe she misunderstood what she was told. We don't know that. But we know that what we have in evidence allegedly is a bullet jacket fragment and four lead fragments of a bullet.
The question is who gets to look at this stuff, and will the defense ever have an opportunity to look at it?
The state filed a motion yesterday. This motion was in response to a defense filing from earlier in the year. The defense had asked for a pause on the examination of the bullet fragment testing. The state, through the FBI, wanted to continue testing the bullet jacket fragment and the different fragments of bullet. The defense asked them to pause on that. The reason they wanted to pause is because there was a concern that the fragments might be damaged or destroyed during the testing. This is very fragile material.
The state through the FBI has already examined it one time. The expert testified at the preliminary hearing and produced a report that she was unable to determine whether that bullet was fired from that particular rifle. That's a big deal. In legal circles we call that reasonable doubt. You've got to have a weapon. You've got to be pretty sure that bullet came from that weapon.
Here's all the defense was asking for. They were not asking to move heaven and earth. They're asking for an opportunity to be present when the additional examination happened, because the state comes and says, "Through the FBI, if we look at this further, there may be damage to this. It could ultimately be destroyed. We're pretty confident it won't, but we can't say for certain. We're going to have to peel the petals back from the bullet jacket fragment with pliers. We're going to have to make little etchings. We're going to have to do all this stuff to it." And the defense says, "Hey, wait a minute. If you're going to change the character of the evidence before we have a chance to look at it, can we at least be there when you do it?" Seems like a fairly reasonable request. Can we at least watch what you're doing to make sure you don't destroy the evidence?
The FBI's Quality Assurance Manual
So the state filed something, and in the filing they included an affidavit from somebody in the FBI. And what that affidavit is saying is: we can't let you be present because our policies don't permit it. We can't let anyone from the defense, we can't let their experts be present, because our policies don't permit it.
Here's how it reads. They have something called the Quality Assurance Manual — FBI Laboratory QAM Revision 7. Notice the date on this revision. I'm not drawing too much attention to the date, but I will point out this revision was 15 days ago. Section 1.8G of this 15-day-old policy states: "Due to security, classification issues, and the sensitivity of cases, the FBI laboratory director restricts access to the FBI laboratory facilities to only FBI laboratory personnel. They will allow authorized non-FBI laboratory personnel and others when escorted by FBI laboratory personnel. Accordingly, the FBI laboratory director prohibits access to the FBI laboratory itself if the purpose of wanting access to the FBI laboratory is for viewing laboratory activities."
In other words, you may not look over our shoulder.
This FBI Laboratory QAM addresses International Standards Organization standards including ISO 17025 and ANAB accreditation requirement AR3125 standards.
So your humble host decides — you know what I've got to do? I've got to figure out what those standards are. Because if you're saying that you're restricting access to the laboratory because you're trying to remain in compliance with this ISO standard and this ANAB standard, I need to know what those standards actually say. I understand the need to stay in compliance with your certification. Otherwise, you can't operate a lab. It's that simple. This is the way it works in the real world. If you work somewhere that does this type of sensitive testing, everybody wants some sort of assurance that what you're doing is right. Everybody wants assurance that things aren't getting lost, things aren't getting mixed up. So there are accrediting standards. ISO is one — the International Standards Organization. What they do is come in and say, if you follow these standards, most people should have confidence in whatever outcome you arrive at. Whether you're testing blood, saliva, bullets, or hair — as long as you follow these standards, we know it was tested properly.
So if you're going to have a policy from the FBI laboratory director that restricts access for the purpose of viewing laboratory activities, and you're going to say the reason we're doing that is because the International Standards Organization mandates it, I wanted to look at the ISO standard to see if it qualified.
ISO 17025 and ANAB Standards — What They Actually Say
Here is the relevant portion of ISO 17025 from section 6.3.4. "Measures to control facilities shall be implemented." We'll just pause right there. They have implemented measures to control the facility — that's their quality assurance manual. That's how it works. You have a set of standards from ISO and you then come up with a set of standards that meet or exceed those standards, and that's the control. So they've done that. We know they have a quality assurance manual. We know they have their certification. So that part's checked.
"The measures shall be monitored and periodically reviewed and shall include but not be limited to access to and use of areas affecting laboratory activities." Well, we know it does that because we saw in the affidavit that they have a policy that addresses access. So section 6.3.4A is checked off.
B: "Prevention of contamination, interference, or adverse influences on laboratory activities." And C: "Effective separation between areas with incompatible laboratory activities." Okay, we're good under this. And maybe the director of the lab is right. Maybe if you read this section, the way to control all this stuff is just to make sure no one's around to observe laboratory activities.
But I wasn't satisfied with that. So I kept digging through the ISO standards and I came across this. This is section 7.1.7: "The laboratory shall cooperate with customers or their representatives in clarifying the customer's request and in monitoring the laboratory's performance in relation to the work performed."
That's exactly what the defense is asking for. We want to monitor your performance in relation to the work being performed. That's the role of the court — to determine whether the defense can do what this section says right here. Can the defense monitor the performance in relation to the work that's being performed? Can we look over your shoulder and watch what you're doing to make sure you're properly analyzing the bullet jacket fragment and the fragments of the bullet itself?
Here's the note: "Such cooperation can include: a) providing reasonable access to relevant areas of the laboratory to witness customer-specific laboratory activities." That's what the defense is asking for. The defense is asking for reasonable access to the relevant areas of the laboratory where the bullet testing is being done, to witness the specific activities relative to that bullet. "b) Preparation, packaging, and dispatch of items needed by the customer for verification purposes."
All they're asking for is permitted by ISO. Permitted by ISO 17025. It's permissible. You can do it. Now, they may have a quality assurance manual that says, well, the way we can make sure nothing ever goes wrong is just to make sure no customers and no representatives from anyone else ever come into the laboratory to watch what we're doing. And that's the route they've chosen to go. But you can't hide behind ISO 17025 and say that your quality assurance manual is in compliance in a way that prevents this. It's too strict. It's stricter than ISO requires. You could dial that back or make a specific exception and still be in compliance with ISO 17025. You're not going to lose your laboratory certification. It says it right there.
Now, she also cited not just ISO 17025 — she cited a requirement from the ANAB that is a supplement to ISO 17025. The way to read these two requirements together is: ISO is the standard, ANAB is the supplement that helps you interpret the standard. Here's what ANAB says about it. This is from section 6.3 and 6.3.4.1, which talks about facilities and environmental conditions: "There shall be a procedure that addresses security and access to areas where testing and calibration occur." Well, they have that — it's the quality assurance manual. But note the note here: "Topics to consider may include, but are not limited to, access to buildings, access by personnel, access by visitors, security during operational hours and non-operational hours, and devices that grant access."
So even the supplement that helps you interpret the ISO standards allows for access by visitors, and the ISO standard itself allows for access by visitors to oversee what's going on to make sure it's meeting the requirements.
Why the Destruction of Evidence Favors the State, Not the Defense
When I look at what the judge is having to decide, I can't help but think that the state is making an argument in their brief that says, "Well, if something happens to the bullet and we can't introduce the bullet, that only favors the defense." I would argue that's not true at all. I would argue it only favors the prosecution.
If I'm the defense, they need to make this argument: if something happens to that bullet and it's destroyed, and the conclusion is anything other than "not a match," then the destruction only favors the state, not the defense. Because right now they're saying it's indeterminate — absent further testing, we can't say whether it is or is not a match. That's the current standing.
Now, if something happens to it, it's not available to be tested by the defense. Well, what if the truth is it's not a match? What if that's the answer? What if that's the true fact — that if this thing is analyzed properly by competent personnel, they will determine it is 100% not a match to the rifle? Just assume that. Now assume it's damaged in this additional testing and the defense did not have access to it and were not present when it happened. So they didn't look over to make sure everything was done properly. They say, "Oh, we did everything right, but we lost the bullet. It's damaged beyond repair. We can't tell. No one will ever know. You're going to have to go to trial without it."
I would argue that only favors the state, because what you've done is removed exculpatory evidence from the body of evidence that will be put in front of the jury. If it's not a match, that's exculpatory — that tends to show Tyler Robinson did not kill Charlie Kirk with a .306 from the Losi Center. You see the problem? The destruction of the evidence, I don't think favors the defense at all. I think it favors the state in a huge way, particularly if it's not a match.
And we know — I don't want to rehash old wounds from this woman — but we know that when she was on the stand, it did not go well for her, because she's only taken one test in history to be certified according to her testimony. And in that test, she said she couldn't tell whether it was a match or not. The correct answer on the test was that it was not a match. So she said she couldn't tell whether it was a match or not, and the correct answer was it's not a match. Well, in Tyler Robinson's case, she said she can't tell whether it's a match or not. What if she's just as incompetent in this case as she was on that test, and it's not a match at all? And now the evidence is gone. And now Tyler Robinson has to go to court without the evidence that could prove that's not the bullet that came from that gun.
This is a real problem. The judge is going to have to get this right. I think this is the first real test of Judge Graf. I think this is the first real test of the criminal defense team. This is the first time they're going to have to lean in and try to make the judge do the right thing. You cannot risk the destruction of evidence that will benefit the state if it's destroyed. You can't. That's not a fair trial.
And again, the goal is not whether Tyler's innocent or guilty. Nobody should be saying we want Tyler Robinson convicted or we want Tyler Robinson acquitted — not at this point. The only thing you should be saying right now is we want a 100% crystal clear fair trial so that everybody in the audience, everybody on the jury, everybody in the courtroom, everybody sitting at home can sleep well that night saying the state of Utah is going to kill a man, but at least he got a fair trial.
This is his first real test on that issue. The preliminary hearing wasn't a real test — it was always kind of a foregone conclusion that it would be bound over for trial. This is his first real test. How is the judge going to handle this hearing? How's the defense going to handle this hearing? What arguments are they going to put forward? And how's the judge going to rule? This should tell us a lot about how this case intends to progress as we continue to go forward. So we're going to keep our eye on it and keep you up to date as it continues to go forward.
The Lindsay Clancy Comparison
Last thing I'll say about this — I noticed Lindsay Clancy is going back to court. Her trial is going back to court. When she goes to court for the second time — her last trial was just a few months ago — when she goes back to court the next time over the death of her children, it will have been four years since the date her children died. Whether she murdered them or not, we don't know yet. It hasn't been declared by a jury. But it will have been four years.
Keep in mind, when Tyler goes to trial, it will have been less than four years. Everybody's panicked about that. I haven't heard anybody complaining about the delay in the Lindsay Clancy case. I saw a lot of people complaining — oh, you know, it's been too long, four years, that's ludicrous, that's an insane amount of time. But when he goes to trial in June of 2029, it will have been less than four years. It'll have been less time than Lindsay Clancy went to trial for the death of her children.
Guys, this is normal stuff. These things take time to get it right. The interest shouldn't be in anything except making sure the defendant gets a fair trial. When we put someone in jail or put them to death, everybody should sleep well at night knowing this country makes sure that when we render justice, it's rendered fairly. We may not agree with the outcome, but we should agree with the process and the procedure.
Top Comments
All right, guys. I want to look at some of the top comments from the last episode.
Oswald's Last Call writes: "It's become abundantly clear they had no idea a lot of people would be looking this closely at every little detail." I guarantee you they didn't know anyone would be looking this closely at every little detail. I think the planning would have been a lot better if they had known that. I'll be honest — Tyler Robinson was not supposed to live. He was supposed to take his own life or be taken out. And the fact that he wasn't really screwed up a lot of things for a lot of people. That's my current position on this whole thing.
Next comment from World Traveler: "Brian Cole Jr. is also being railroaded and is in jail. He should be home with his family. All this is beyond fed slop. It's diabolical." Stay tuned on that. We may have a really fun show next week on that. I'm trying to get it planned and put together. But if you're interested in the Brian Cole Jr. story, next Tuesday may be a really, really good show. You might want to set a calendar reminder for that. I'm trying to get that settled and scheduled, but if we get it done, it'll be stellar. I promise you.
Top comments from today. VS Damon writes: "Don't fear the technology. Fear the man behind it. Humans only recreate what already is. All intelligence is His, not Satan's creation. But humans can be led by Satan or God. How about we flip the tables and stop losing to Satan?" Well, that's what I was saying. Water flows downhill. There have always been bad people, and the bad people are going to use whatever technology is available to them to do bad things — whether it's a firearm, AI technology, or the US Postal Service. People have committed serious fraud using mail carriers. So I agree with you. But when you invent technology, you should say, "Hey, how could this be used for bad?" And if the bad means the end of humanity or the wiping out of everyone's wealth and the utter destitute poverty of everyone on earth, maybe we pump the brakes a little bit until we figure it out a little better.
Linds B writes: "Good evening to all. Baron, you're doing a fantastic job. And Candace Conrad is so stinking cute. Christ is king indeed." He is stinking cute. I saw him again today. What a stinking cute little kid.
Jason Bourne's Wife checks in: "Normal is not returning, but Jesus is coming soon. Get right with him. He loves you." Jesus does love you. There's no doubt about it. And there's nothing you can do to change it. Thanks for all your hard work, Baron. You're doing a great job. Thank you. I appreciate that. Very kind of you.
Irish Mom writes: "Hey Baron, you were excellent on Sunday. One of your best shows." Thank you. If you've not checked it out, over on Baron Coleman — you can search that on YouTube and find it. We have a lot of fun over there. "You're cooking on Candace too. Way to go." Thank you, Irish Mom.
Renie says: "Hey Baron, in my opinion, these attacks are a way to rush in data centers. Your thoughts? Christ is king indeed." I don't know, because the data centers, in my opinion, make these attacks more likely. So I don't know that the beauty is in the eye of the beholder there.
WBU writes: "Just in — fire reported at the CIA office." Daily Express just reported a small electrical fire at the CIA headquarters in Langley, Virginia. Well, I don't wish anyone harm, but that doesn't apply to buildings.
You notice something? You notice these attacks never benefit us — the people, the plebes. You notice they never benefit us. It might wipe out your retirement. Well, did it wipe out Bill Gates's retirement? Did it wipe out Donald Trump's retirement? No. Oh, they're attacking American infrastructure. Well, did they attack any other particular country's infrastructure? Technological people in the Middle East that hold a lot of technological infrastructure — do they ever attack their infrastructure? Things I notice. I'm a noticing guy. I can't help it.